Tim Urban American Idol February 24 Apologize

Tim Urban, the Chris Golightly replacement in American Idol 2010 Top 24, chose to sing OneRepublic's "Apologize". I think it was a train wreck... bad falsettos and forgotten lyrics. Simon Cowell could not even hide his frustration as he said that making him go home (after the first 24 contestants with Chris) were chosen was right.

All other judges agreed with Simon. Ellen DeGeneres said that "none of it worked” and she said that Tim "couldn’t hit those high notes.” Everyone agreed he’ll get votes because he’s just "cute" and not because he's a good singer. Tim had an excuse as the song was a last minute switch. Anyway, just look at Tim Urban shirtless photos and you be the judge if you want him in or out.

Aaron Kelly American Idol February 24 Here Comes Goodbye

Aaron Kelly is kind of the "David Archuleta" American Idol Season 9. He's 16 year old and wide-eyed, kind of nervous. Aaron sang "Here Comes Goodbye" by Rascall Flatts

Of course, judges love this cute boy with cute boys. It's a way to get tweens to watch this show! Simon said: ”It actually was quite a good performance…you look as if you are embarrassed to be there…you have to take control of the song…absolutely you will be here next week.” Kara agreed by saying: “You have no idea what your talent is…I like the pop country lane for you… I think you did a great job… We’re going to see incredible things from you.” Randy thought that Aaron Kelly has "a huge voice" and that he's a big fan. Watch Aaron Kelly's Here Come Goodbye performance below:

.

Todrick Hall American Idol February 24 Since U Been Gone

Todrick Hall came out first in the American Idol Top 12 boys. He sang Kelly Clarkson's Since U Been Gone. I could nearly recognize the song because he twisted it that it became too different from the original.

The judges all found the performance good on stage but the vocals just so-so. Simon Cowell even said it was a "crazy arrangement" and Todrick "murdered" the original song. The whole thing was "verging on stupid". Watch his performance below to see if it Todrick is going to stay or going home tomorrow: